Description: About three things I was absolutely positive: First, Edward was a vampire. Second, there was a part of him–and I didn’t know how dominant that part might be–that thirsted for my blood. And third, I was unconditionally and irrevocably in love with him.Review:
While this is an easy read and I admire the way Meyer blends the realistic with the fantastical so seamlessly, Twilight ultimately falls flat. A major part of this is due to the pacing. The writing style draws you in to the suspense, but it is stretched out to the point where the narrative becomes slow and seems plotless. This may be because it concentrates so heavily on Bella and Edward’s romantic relationship. I have nothing wrong with romances, but they generally have a larger plot peppered throughout it as well, not squeezed into the last portion of the book, making it feel forced and uncharacteristic to the novel’s earlier tone.
The characters are also another quibble of mine. Meyer does have the ability to create fleshed-out, relatable characters -- at least, where Jacob and Charlie are concerned. They both had quirks and flaws that made the story more tangible and enjoyable. Other characters show some these things in their personality as well, but not enough to make me fully care about them. Bella and Edward are the two characters that turned me off the most. (And, sadly, the major characters in the book.) I liked Bella in the beginning, but she soon turned out to be nothing but a plot device as she was placed in certain dangerous situations. Her obsession with Edward is also appalling, for she constantly refers to him as someone who is perfect and flawless which ends up diminishing any self-confidence she might have had. Edward is, in fact, perfect and flawless, at least in context, and that’s where I start to really have issues. He may be a vampire and privy to certain abilities, but the core of his character shouldn’t be perfect as well. Perfect is boring and unreal, making me unsympathetic of his character. He’s virtually a cardboard cut-out, and who wants to read about cardboard?
Twilight does have its good moments, with a flowing pose, original vampire mythos, witty comments, and glimpses of some very endearing characters, but its flaws outweigh the good. In fact, there were several times where I felt compelled to stop, and for a majority of the book I would not have had regretted that decision. Nothing about it drove me to find out what happened next, and that’s a bad trait for a book to have.

10 comments:
Oi, achei teu blog pelo google tá bem interessante gostei desse post. Quando der dá uma passada pelo meu blog, é sobre camisetas personalizadas, mostra passo a passo como criar uma camiseta personalizada bem maneira. Até mais.
This book was an amazing book, and an excellent beginning to the 4 book series. I can't wait til the 4th book comes out. Twilight was so good that I read it in about 3 hours. Also, apparently Hollywood thought it was good because the movie hits theaters this December. I've also read marked and betrayed (house of night series) and I would have to say that the twilight series is far better. Then again we all have our opinions.
I would have to agree with Stephanie about the Twilight series being much better than the House of Night series. I haven't met a person yet on any blog that didn't think the same until now. And you even rated The Morganville Vampires series higher...neither of the two come close to matching the Twilight series. There's just so much real suspense and you even feel like you are Bella at times in Twilight. House of Night and Morganville Vampires...both have so much unbelievable drama going on...I keep thinking the whole time...this is ridiculous! And there is so much drama in both series' that the authors seemed to have forgotten some things and little things go missing throughout the storyline. A few spots I was clueless and wondering..."Hey what happened to...this or that!?!" But all 3 are very entertaining I just totally disagree with the rating you gave the Twilight series. And I hope no one misses out on this series because of the harsh review you gave it. Twilight (Book 1), New Moon (Book 2) and Eclipse (Book 3) have all been on the New York Times Best Sellers list...but then again everyone is entilted totheir own opinion.
I have to say that i agree with Stephanie and Crystal 100 percent.. Twilight is an AMAZING book. the house of night series is also really good but in my opinion Twilight was MUCH better. People shouldnt miss out on this book!!
I cant wait for 4th book, and the movie.
I have to agree with nothing that they are saying. Twilight is OKAY, but some treat it as if it were the holy bible. I think the characters are flat and the central basis of how the only reason Bella loves Edward is, let's be honest here, because of his beautiful face is old.
are you fucking insane?? it the BEST book. edward isnt perfect. he's over protctive and worries too much. you should review the other ones. twilight is AMAZING. its not an opinion, its a fact. you're the first person i've heard of who hasnt liked the book. the feeling you get when edward and bella are together.... Its amamzing. i'm sad it's coming to an end since the fourth one is the last one in bellas pov.
Twilight is siimply THE BEST (L)
I love it
i have read the book betrayed and i loved it but now that i no that there is other books out there i am going to get them all..
cant wait to read what happends to zoey and her friends.
your reader
ashley
i have read the book betrayed and i loved it but now that i no that there is other books out there i am going to get them all..
cant wait to read what happends to zoey and her friends.
your reader
ashley
Twilight is an amazing book (and I should know, I'm a really devoted reader). This book is amazing! The romance, action, and, my favorite, the sarcasm. I'm very young (12 yrs old) and I managed to read the wholes series by my birthday. Best B-day present ever (Breaking Dawn). I just hope that the new director can do a better job than the last one.
Post a Comment