In honor of Halloween this month, I’ve decided to make a list of characters who have left an impression on me throughout the years because of their—what else?—creepiness! With fantasy’s tendency to lean toward the horrific, this list could get real long, real fast, so I’m just going to name a few for now. Hopefully I can spotlight more creepy characters for future Octobers! Is one of your favorites a part of this list? Or have I ridiculously forgotten to list someone you think deserves a mention
right now? Sound off in the comments!
Edward Cullen
“I’m essentially a selfish creature. I crave your company too much to do what I should.”
—Edward
As Seen In: The
Twilight series by
Stephenie Meyer
Why He’s Creepy: I tried refraining from mentioning Edward in a list like this, since I know he’s not
supposed to be creepy, but…
come on. When he’s not being downright stalkery, he’s over-controlling and possessive. Forget vampires;
this kind of monster—too easily found in the real world—is the thing that gives me nightmares.
The Fairy King
So the Fairy King reached out with his long, ghostly fingers…and ate her soul.
As Seen In: The Dreaming series by
Queenie Chan
Why He’s Creepy: This entire manga is full of creepy characters, but if I have to narrow it down to just one for this list, I’m going to go with the Fairy King, since a lot of the creepiness that happens throughout the series wouldn’t have been possible without him. If you thought making a deal with the Devil was bad, wait until you make a deal with a quinkan….
Gravedigger
His face broke into a hideous grin that stretched the width of his skeletal head like a gruesome gash.
As Seen In: The
Morpheus Road series by
D. J. MacHale
Why He’s Creepy: Has Gravedigger inexplicably been brought to life from a stack of drawings, or is he just a figment of your imagination? Doesn’t matter, because one way or another, this thing is haunting you until he gets what he wants—in this case, your life—and nothing he does to persuade you involves something as pleasant as a “please.” (It may, however, involve a silver pick….)
Harold the Scarecrow
“There really is nothing to be afraid of,” they told one another. “After all, what can a doll do?”
As Seen In: Scary Stories Treasury by Alvin Schwartz; illustrated by Stephen Gammell
Why He’s Creepy: As a kid, Harold’s story—creatively titled “Harold”—is one that always stuck out to me when reading (and rereading!) this series. Considering how this scarecrow has no qualms skinning you and hanging your bloody hide up to dry, is it really that much of a surprise that it did?
Him
With one quick decision he could determine if they awakened tomorrow, or if they languished for hours or days on end, or if their hearts stopped suddenly, midbeat, without the slightest warning.
As Seen In: The Unseen series by
Richie Tankersley Cusick
Why He’s Creepy: This supernatural stalker—from a breed so shrouded, no one has a name for them—can take the guise of anyone, as well as show up anywhere, anytime. When he sets his sights out for something—or, rather,
someone—don’t expect your life to stay normal for long…if he even lets you live.
Regulators
He sensed his body bleeding into the Regulator, becoming part of her essence…
As Seen In: The
Daughters of the Moon and
Sons of the Dark series by Lynne Ewing
Why They’re Creepy: They can look supermodel perfect—better than supermodel perfect, even—but that’s only when they bother shapeshifting to look “normal” while traipsing through our world. Evil has deformed their true appearance, making them monstrous inside and out. But don’t worry, they won’t kill you—they’ll just absorb you into their bodies, dooming you to spend eternity seeing life through
their eyes as they do their malicious deeds.
The Shadow Men
It looked down at Jenny with its crocodile eyes: ancient, pitiless, and endlessly malevolent.
As Seen In: The Forbidden Game series by
L. J. Smith
Why They’re Creepy: Although born beautiful, they grow grotesque with age, to better match the evil within them. (How grotesque? Well, some can be described as looking like a “withered fetus,” for one thing….) These creatures, from a nefarious realm called the Shadow World, like bringing nightmares to life and playing games with humans. (No, not of the
Monopoly variety.) What they like even more, however, is souls, and they will stop at nothing to possess
yours.